A few nights ago in Woolongong on a cold night I decided to rent ‘Doubt’, a story based in a religious institution but more about the human condition in general than simply people of faith.
Despite falling asleep and snoring loudly for 15 minutes of it, I was still impressed by its careful and nuanced storyline. I felt it could easily have been retitled ‘Fear’ as this emotion pervaded the story to an equal degree.
Doubt is the story of a progressive priest in a Catholic school who is seen as a threat by the super-conservative principal nun. His long fingernails and use of a ballpoint pen instead of a fountain pen cause her to question the very core of his character and ultimately lead her to a place of character assassination to try and rid her life of this non-conforming and disturbing man.
Part of the genius of the movie is that we aren’t sure who are the ‘goodies’ and who are the ‘baddies’, but then maybe that is the whole point? No one is ever ‘all good’ or ‘all bad’.
The final scene of the movie is brilliant as it shows just what is at the core of Sister Aloysius’ own struggles and reveals the conflicted nature of so many who appear to be so righteous and who ‘need’ to denounce others who don’t share their high standards.
There aren’t many movies I like to watch twice, but I’ll be revisiting that one once it hits the weekly shelves.
I have enjoyed reading about your travels with your family around Australia and your thoughts on faith, Jesus, church and everything in between. I was interested in your interpretation of ‘Doubt’and I was wondering how much your sympathy for those who are ‘progressive’ might have influenced how you felt about the characters?
Hi LisA – maybe a bit, but I am def more influenced by a disdain for the methods used by sister A – I find her abhorrent and she provokes my strongest reaction.
I saw this movie a few months ago and loved it
so very very human
It also reminded me of something I wrote on my blog a couple of years ago: It seems to me that if someone has to make others feel broken, then they themselves must have a sizeable brokenness.