
An observation – untested – but I would suggest largely true – is that evangelicalism is heavily populated with white collar workers.
Why is it that are our churches generally composed of people with higher education, or those who work in professional / corporate roles?
As I began to look around for churches where tradespeople are the larger group I found myself coming up short. Even in the classic blue collar suburbs of Perth, the church is generally still heavily composed of middle class, more educated people.
It’s difficult to write of this without the distinction between degrees of education sounding disparaging. Often a trade was often presented to us as the only option for the less academic sorts. When I was a student a significant number left at the age of 15 – currently the end of year 10 – and found a trade/apprenticeship where they learnt on the job and with some TAFE based education. I remember thinking ‘ok so the smart people keep studying while the rest ‘drop out’. You can hear the pejorative thinking around this subject.
While that mindset may still be present to a lesser degree today, I feel like we have come to recognise different forms of intelligence. I have friends who can pull apart car engines, hang doors and fix a leaking pipe in their sleep. Some academic types have never invested time in practical learning so they feel all at sea in this regard.
There are obviously many many people in our communities who build & fix things, or who work in jobs where higher education is not required, but they are under-represented in our churches. If I had to offer a few un-researched reasons for this these are what they’d be:
a) People like me – most of us join groups where the other people are somewhat like us. It’s just a sociological norm – ‘like’ hangs with ‘like’. And over the many years as the evangelical work ethic has done its thing the church has become increasingly a place for those who have moved out of a working class space and into a more middle class life. In days gone by tradies didn’t earn as much as teachers, so the lack of earning generally made for a harder life. This is no longer the case for many trade workers who can now make a lot of money doing the jobs that people simply don’t know how to do or can’t be bothered doing. Despite this change in income levels, there is still a difference in education that can cause a feeling of superiority or inadequacy.
b) Learning style – In most of evangelicalism the sermon is the centrepiece of the Sunday experience. It’s possible that the form alone isolates some practical people. Sitting and listening is not their learning style and unless the speaker is genuinely engaging they will likely be bored in minutes. When preaching is heavy on the exegesis and abstract theological ideas, tradies may simply detach. If they are faced with a form of thinking that doesn’t express itself practically then I suggest they zone out and eventually drop out. The dominance of sermon style communication can often say ‘you don’t belong here’ as this message doesn’t have a direct correlation to the life you live.
c) They need a day off – all work is tiring but physical labour is very tiring. Many trades also work 6 days / week so the thought of spending a Sunday in a room with people ‘unlike me’, listening to what may be seen as an irrelevant lecture is gonna be a stretch. Even those of us who work 5 days know that Saturday is when all the jobs get done around the house so space in the week can be hard to find.
d) Culture – compare the vibe of the building site with that of the school staff room or the office and generally there is a perception that the culture in these work areas is quite different. Generous slatherings of expletives are common on building sites, but not so in office settings. The attire of each environment also communicates something – work boots, hard hats and work wear ‘feels’ different to collared shirts and maybe even ties. The language and tone of the work site doesn’t feel like it belongs in the church gathering, but (and I know I am generalising) the tone of the office feels more akin to a Sunday space. Generally speaking we have done better at relaxing our expectations of dress-code around church so that thongs and t shirt is now quite acceptable in some communities. We no longer frown at those who smoke or swear, but I sense we still give off a more ‘proper’ tone than is gonna make the average tradie feel at ease.
Perhaps a valuable point of leverage may be engaging tradespeople more intentionally into church leadership teams. When I think of virtually every leadership team or board I have been part of, the demographic missing is always the blue collar. I wonder why that is… I don’t sense tradespeople are better or worse in leadership capacity than the average corporate type. Maybe the skills of a board are better suited to those in professional roles, but I’d suggest we would do well to find a way to raise up leaders who do not live in white collar world. Not that it’s bad to have a professional job – but it is a concern that we seem to be lacking these people in our church communities.
Anyway I’d love to hear your comments and observations. A friend suggested to me recently that the ethnic churches (Vietnamese / Burmese etc) have a higher representation of trades, perhaps because these folks are needing to re-orient their lives in a new country where their quals are unrecognised.
Another random comment from a friend was about the ‘right leaning’ of more tradespeople today. What used to be a politically left demographic does seem to have shifted. Or is that just me?…

So those are a few reasons I see for the conundrum we find ourselves in, but what can we do to somehow broaden the reach of our church communities. Is it even possible to see a significant non-professional/corporate/academic demographic represented in our churches.
Just reflecting on your post, I’ve always had blue collar workers as part of my leadership teams and I reckon it has a bit to do with the city/country divide. In my experience, most rural churches attract a broader cross-section of people and are more receptive to connecting with a wide range of people, than city churches.
yeah i reckon the bush probably has more blue collar creew